The effect of subunit vaccination on the incidence and severity of primary and recurrent genital herpes was investigated in the female guinea pig model of herpes simplex virus (HSV) type 2 genital infection. After prophylactic immunization with zwitterionic detergent-solubilized HSV-1 glycoproteins formulated with alhydrogel or as immunostimulating complex particles, significant reductions in the incidence and severity of primary herpetic illness were observed in both vaccinated groups compared with immunization-naive controls. There was a significant reduction in the incidence of spontaneous herpetic recurrences after administration of HSV-1 antigens formulated as immunostimulatory complexes to guinea pigs in a prophylactic mode (P < .01). Increased levels of both postimmunization and postchallenge ELISA and neutralizing antibodies were significant correlates of protection against primary herpetic disease in a prophylactic scenario. However, no correlation was observed between elevated ELISA or neutralizing antibody levels and protection against recurrent disease following prophylactic or therapeutic administration of HSV-1 subunit vaccines.